Learn March 20th,2023

How to Tell if Wine Has Gone Bad

On this Page:

Knowing if a bottle of wine is faulty is not too difficult. In this article, we’ll focus on several tips to help you recognise if this has happened to your wine.

Wine Going Bad in a Nutshell

Before even opening the bottle, you might be able to see whether the wine has expired. It may be a brownish colour, or the cork might be a little pushed out from the bottle, meaning the wine has expanded or overheated.

When you uncork the bottle, two are the main signs you should focus on which will tell you if it is past its prime:

  • The wine smell:

    it has a mouldy or vinegar-like smell

  • The wine taste:

    the wine seems to be fizzy or effervescent when it shouldn’t be sparkling

Can Wine Go Bad?

Some of you might have heard that wine can last indefinitely, but it’s more complicated than that. If the wine is unopened, then it can certainly last for a long time, some high quality examples lasting several years. Unfortunately however, regular wines tend to expire after a few years of storage. So make sure to read the label and check this information prior to your purchase.

Why Does Wine Go Bad?

The reasons why wine goes bad can depend on several factors. After a couple of years, bottles can overheat, causing the wine to lose its flavor and aroma, or the cork might start to let some air into the bottle, therefore causing the wine to oxidise.

How to Recognise Bad Wine

The Look

Even before opening, smelling, and tasting the wine, you might still be able to spot if a bottle has expired by its look. When a wine is exposed to oxygen - because the cork has let in some air - it will become brown in colour. If it is very brown, you may find that a lot of oxidation has occurred.

Red wines tend to show a brown hue, while white wines usually become either deep yellow or light brown, depending on the oxidation level. Generally, the more brown a wine is, the more oxidised it is.

The Smell

One of the first factors to consider when you’re trying to recognise bad wine is the smell.

Flavours that are common in wine faults are acetone (which smells like nail varnish remover or nail polish), vinegar, mould like in a musty basement, or a strong raisined smell.

Smells like these means that bacteria was free to grow inside the bottle and produce compounds like acetic acid.

The Taste

When you taste a faulty wine, you’ll probably immediately recognise if it has gone bad, especially if you already recognised the brownish colour and sour smell. Bad wine is usually characterised by a sharp and sour flavour that resembles vinegar and, in addition, due to the oxidation, you might notice a caramelised flavor that is similar to that of apple sauce.

Furthermore, if a still wine is fizzy or effervescent, then that’s a sign a second fermentation has occurred in the bottle and the wine shouldn’t be drunk.

Rest assured, faulty wines shouldn’t cause you any harm, but they are not pleasant to drink.

What Can You Do with Bad Wine?

Usually, faulty wine should be thrown away, however, it can sometimes be used in the kitchen. Old wine for instance can be used to marinate meat or even used to make wine jelly.

Summary of All the Signs of Bad Wine

  • Pushed out cork:

    One of the clearest signs of wines stored in a hot place is a slightly protruded cork that extends from the bottle.

  • Brownish colour:

    White and red wines both tend to become brown when they’ve been exposed to oxygen

  • Fizz:

    When a still wine is fizzy or effervescent, it could have been subject to an unintentional second fermentation inside the bottle

  • Faded colour:

    Although classic aged wines tend to become brown when they’re past their prime, younger wines usually fade in colour

  • Vinegar smell:

    You might notice a strong and sour vinegar smell which is the product of unwanted bacteria activity in the bottle

  • Moldy smell:

    A mouldy smell can indicate that the cork had mold growing on it, or that the wine is ‘corked’ (this is when a bacteria called TCA is present in the cork and makes the wine smell like a damp basement).

  • Nail polish smell:

    A heavy nail polish or nail polish remover smell is an indication of too much acetic acid in the bottle

  • Raisin smell:

    Even though a wine can feature a fruity or flowery aroma, if the smell of raisins is too much then that means the wine has gone bad

  • Sweet red wine:

    When a red wine tastes uncharacteristically sweet, then it means the bottle has overheated and is undrinkable

  • Sherried flavors:

    This happens in wines that have oxidised

FAQs

How to Tell if Wine Is Off Without Opening the Bottle?

There are two main signs to focus on, the wine colour and the cork. Colour changes are a sign of oxidation. If the wine is faded, dull or brown, then the bottle is most likely past its prime. If you notice the cork is slightly pushed out from the bottle more than it should be, then that’s a sign the wine might have overheated or expanded. Usually, this is due to improper storage.

How do you know if red wine has gone bad?

Expired red wine is usually characterised by an overly sweet taste, a dark or brownish colour, and an overpowering sour or unpleasant smell. You also might notice effervescence in a still wine.

How do you know if white wine has gone bad?

White wine will turn a darker colour due to oxidation. This can be a deep yellow or a light brown. In addition, you may find a vinegar smell or a slightly pushed out cork.

What happens if you drink wine that's gone bad?

Although expired wine doesn’t have a nice taste, drinking it isn’t going to cause you any harm. If anything, oxidation might cause you to feel some stinging in your mouth, but it’s nothing to worry too much about.